Premium is easy to imitate. Distinctive brand meaning isn’t.

By Ben Martin – Founder & Creative Director, Royal Flush

Premium has always had a visual language.

Gold foils, matt substrates, restrained typography, elegant photography, provenance cues and considered use of space have all become familiar ways of telling us that a product sits above the everyday. More recently, a different version of premium has emerged: oversized display type, bubble fonts, clashing colour palettes, psychedelic illustration and a deliberately quirky visual confidence.

None of those things is inherently wrong. The problem starts when a visual cue becomes a shortcut.

Once enough brands adopt the same aesthetic, what originally looked distinctive becomes another category trope. Ten brands can all be trying to look unconventional and somehow end up looking remarkably similar.

We have seen this cycle before. Minimalism became shorthand for premium and contemporary design, influenced by brands such as Apple and long-established luxury houses. At its best, minimalism can be beautifully distinctive because every decision matters: proportion, typography, material, colour and restraint. At its weakest, it becomes an instruction to ‘make it look like Apple’, with the surface aesthetic copied but none of the thinking underneath it.

The same thing happened with the hipster visual language of the 2010s. There was a period when seemingly every craft product needed a handlebar moustache, crossed tools, badges or faux heritage typography. It looked current until suddenly it did not.

Today, maximalism risks running through the same cycle. Oversized display type, bubble fonts, clashing colours, psychedelic illustration and deliberately exaggerated quirkiness can feel fresh and expressive, but once enough brands adopt the same language, the style itself starts doing less of the differentiating work.

A trend can make a brand feel current. It cannot make it distinctive on its own.

That matters because packaging is expensive to replace. If a brand needs a wholesale redesign in two or three years simply because its look has fallen out of fashion, it is worth asking whether it ever had a sufficiently strong identity in the first place.

Refreshes are normal. Brands should evolve. But style should be capable of changing without requiring the brand itself to change.

A useful way to think about this is to imagine a brand as a person. The same person can wear a suit, sportswear, evening clothes or something deliberately fashionable and still be recognisably themselves. A strong brand should be able to do the same.

It should be able to change its clothes without changing who it is.

That means the work before design becomes critical.

Before choosing typefaces, colours, illustration styles or finishes, we should be asking much more fundamental questions. Who is this brand? What are its identifiable traits? How is it positioned? What does it believe? Who is it trying to align with? What problem does it solve? Why does it exist?

And crucially, who is the customer?

Consumers are increasingly sophisticated at reading brands, even when that judgement is subconscious. They may not be able to explain exactly why something feels right, authentic or desirable, but they can sense when the styling, messaging and proposition belong together and when they do not.

That is why messaging matters so much.

A brand can look fashionable and still feel hollow if the visual expression does not match what it is saying, who it is for or the world it wants to belong in. The strongest brands create a deeper connection because the identity, tone of voice, product and presentation all reinforce the same idea.

When we are talking about packaging, the styling can evolve to remain contemporary. When we are talking about brand, the identity is the deeper layer that creates the gut feeling consumers respond to.

Does this fit into my world? Does this feel like something for me? Would I be happy to put it in my basket, serve it to friends or leave it on the shelf at home?

Those questions matter because design does not exist independently of the commercial context it has to operate within. A 55p flapjack sold through a value retailer should not necessarily look like a luxury confectionery product. If its packaging communicates a price and experience wildly disconnected from the product and channel, the design may be attractive but it is not doing its job.

That is the distinction between fine art and commercial design.

As commercial designers, our responsibility is not simply to produce something aesthetically interesting. We have to create something appropriate to the customer, the proposition, the price, the occasion and the place where the product will be bought.

Is it an impulse purchase? A convenience product? A treat? A gift? An everyday staple? A luxury? A budget choice?

Those answers should shape the visual expression far more than whatever happens to be fashionable in design feeds that year.

There is nothing wrong with using trends. They are part of the visual culture in which brands exist, and ignoring them completely can make a brand feel equally disconnected. The skill is using contemporary styling to express an identity rather than allowing the styling to become the identity.

That is where distinctive brand meaning becomes harder to imitate.

Competitors can use the same foil. Retailers can commission the same matt pouch. Anyone can choose a similar display font or colour palette. AI will make stylistic replication faster and easier still.

What is harder to reproduce is a brand with a clear personality, an identifiable point of view, genuine provenance, accumulated recognition and a reason for existing that extends beyond its packaging.

Premium design therefore cannot simply be about looking more expensive than the product beside you.

The harder and more valuable task is creating an identity strong enough to remain recognisable when the fashion changes.

Ben Martin is Founder and Creative Director of Royal Flush, a brand strategy, identity and packaging consultancy specialising in food, drink and hospitality. He works with challenger and established brands to define positioning, build distinctive identities and create packaging that connects commercial strategy with how people actually experience and choose brands.

By Ben Martin – Founder & Creative Director, Royal Flush

You must be logged in to post a comment Login